“The Fifty Year Sword” by Mark Z. Danielewski

“The Fifty Year Sword” by Mark Z. Danielewski  (2012) – 298 pages

sword 

No writer has had more success creating a mind-bending mystique around his books than Mark Z. Danielewski (from here on referred to as Mark Z.).  His first book, “House of Leaves”, had an unconventional page layout and style with backwards text, a maze-like story, copious footnotes, etc.  It was widely acclaimed, and his next novel “Only Revolutions” also had unusual format features and was a finalist for the National Book Award for Fiction.

By now Mark Z. has a large cult following and there are web sites wholly devoted to discussions of each of his books.   “The Fifty Year Sword” was first released in a very limited edition.  Then Mark Z. put together well-attended Halloween performances of the novel.  Now “The Fifty Year Sword” has been published in quite lavish fashion.  What started as a 50-page horror story has been turned into a 298-page novel with ‘stitchings’ by Atelier Z. instead of drawings and lots and lots of blank space and blank high-quality pages.

tumblr_mc9ymjJEON1qzrfxgo1_400I don’t know.  First of all I was not at all aware of the mystique surrounding it when I read “The Fifty Year Sword”.  The ‘stitchings’ did nothing for me; they seemed more like random scribble drawings rather than in any way illustrating or representing the story.   The story is OK but nothing special, a Halloween story centering on the sword.  The story is not particularly intriguing, certainly not as scary as the famous Edgar Allan Poe horror stories. In the book there is a system of color-coded quotes which was completely lost on me.  Couldn’t the author just write “Chintana said” or “Belinda Kite replied”?    That would not have been half so precious but a hundred times clearer.    

 Another characteristic of “The Fifty Year Sword” is the use by Mark Z. of words that will never be found in the dictionary.

  “Too many hours, shoomed the Social Worker, gratefully accepatating Chintana’s concoctions.” 

In the sentence above, ‘shoomed” seems a good use of a made-up word, but it is questionable that ‘accepatating’ works any better than ‘accepting’.  Quite a few of the made up words added nothing to the word they were adapted from. 

 By now Mark Z. has become an industry, not just a writer.  There are speculators who buy copies of his limited editions on eBay in the hopes they will go up in value, and one guy wrote on Amazon that he was disappointed that this new edition of “The Seven Year Sword” was published for wide release.  Mark Z. recently won a seven-figure advance for the first 10 books of a planned 27-volume serial novel called at this point “The Familiar”.    

 I don’t begrudge any writer being financially successful, but somehow it seems that at least for this book, Mark Z. is like the Wizard of Oz, doing it with smoke, mirrors and other gimmicks.

About these ads

4 responses to this post.

  1. I suppose there are people who collect books but for me they’re just so much clutter – its the content that matters not the presentation in my humble opinion. But one is tempted to suggest that this one may be all style and little substance judging from your review. Interesting though – a write I have never heard of before

    Reply

    • Hi Tom,
      “House Of Leaves” got a lot of positive reviews here in the US 12 years ago when it was published, I very much intended to read it. However it was quite expensive with its unusual format and all. Libraries naturally hesitated to get it. Also it was quite a long book, so I never got around to reading it. Somehow I missed ‘Only Revolutions’, but when i saw ‘Swords’ I saw a chance to read Mark z. – not impressed.

      Reply

  2. Having read and adored (without understanding why at all) House of Leaves when it first came out – I’m going to have to investigate this one further. HoL was so unlike anything else I’d ever read. I suspect slightly though, that it may not live up to re-reading. Hmm!

    Reply

    • Hi Gaskella,
      I had considerable interest in reading “House of Leaves” when it came out and got all those positive reviews. But somehow I never got to it Then somehow I missed ‘Only Revolutions’. Didn’t get to Mark z. until ‘The Fifty Year Sword’.. It’s always good to have an author who is new and different whether or not I’m impressed by their books.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 277 other followers

%d bloggers like this: